Single malt whisky - tasting notes

18 Oct 2010

Port Ellen Pe2 (Elements of Islay)

Posted by: Ruben Luyten In: Port Ellen

Port Ellen PE1 was talk of the town in 2009. It was highly sought after with exceptional prices in auctions. Its successor, Port Ellen PE2, was sold out in just around 24 hours, but the hype seemed a bit smaller afterwards.

With Port Ellen PE3 knocking on the door, it’s time to review PE2.

 

Port Ellen PE2 Port Ellen Pe2
(59,5%, Elements of Islay 2010, 50 cl.)

Nose: starts on very dark chocolate and gunpowder. Notes of burnt wood that seem less strong in PE1. There’s a sherried sweetness in the background, but it’s not extremely fruity (no apples or raspberry like in PE1). Instead there’s an organic / slightly dirty / damp side to it that I find a bit difficult to appreciate. Aged meat. A rather dominant smell of a tyre shop. Some tobacco and liquorice. Quite “dark” overall – PE1 seems fresher and more vibrant. Water highlights the sulphury matchsticks and mustiness. Mouth: intense with coal smoke, soot and tar. The peat is nicely countered by cocoa sweetness and spices but again the fruitiness is buried deep inside. Chili and ginger. Grows drier and spicier over time, with added notes of liquorice. Water doesn’t add much, it just gets less powerful. Finish: medium length, rather sweet with hints of pepper and savoury meat sauce.

Sometimes it’s a fine line… when tasting PE2 on its own, it seemed very similar to PE1, although I couldn’t put my finger on the differences. After a direct comparison, it’s clear that the successor is sweeter yet less fruity, with a slightly bigger focus on sulphury notes and rubber. Around € 140 at the time, now sold out (unless you want to pay much more).

Score: 89/100

 

Port Ellen PE3

 

Port Ellen PE3
(54%, Elements of Islay 2010, 50 cl.)

The third heir in the PE family – PE3 –  has been announced. Judging by the colour, it will not be a sherry cask this time. It’s safe to expect a completely different profile.

It will be bottled at 54% and sold for € 215,
a significant step up from the previous editions
(i.e. € 300 for 70cl – probably not far from the official Port Ellen 10th release). Keep an eye on the TWE or LMdW websites if you want to get this.

Port Ellen Pe2 (Elements of Islay) 4 Ruben Luyten 2010-10-18
  • http://www.whivie.be Mark Dermul

    While I feel lucky to have PE1 in my cabinet, I don’t feel the need to own PE2 (since they seem so similar). But this upcoming PE3 will indeed be entirely different. Unfortunately, I believe at 215 EUR it is too expensive. Do you think that has to do with the quality or is that merely market influence (seeing that both previous editions sold out so quickly)?

  • http://www.whiskynotes.be Ruben

    I guess both explanations are plausible. If something is so limited and sells out in 24 hours, marketeers usually say it’s underpriced. On the other hand it’s possible that the PE3 cask was bought from another broker which could explain the different pricing. I don’t think the quality alone can explain such a price increase, even if it would be as good as the Port Ellen for The Whisky Show 2009.
    Other Port Ellen news: Malts of Scotland has announced a refill sherry Port Ellen 1983. It will be around € 185 (70 cl).

  • Maie

    They are also all available in belgium… Crombé, Fisser, Tasttoe, Broekmans etc

  • http://www.whiskysite.nl Whiskysite

    We had 3 bottles in subscription… gone in 1 hour ;-)

    Its more expensive is told because it a 70′s bottling… others were 80′s!

    Jack

  • Pingback: Malt Maniacs Awards 2010 | WhiskyNotes

Categories

Calendar

September 2014
M T W T F S S
« Aug    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

  • Jorn: I agree, the first expressions tend to go up in value the most, - ofcourse -, but do you really think the Bowmore DC 2 will sink below 150,00 euro? N
  • WhiskyNotes: I tend to disagree. I would just wait for n°III and make sure you inform your favourite retailer that you want one beforehand. Buying a hyped product
  • Jorn: It's worth 150 allright, but mainly from a collector's point of view. That's where the market is. Like precious little stamps (Nothing wrong with that

Coming up

  • Tomatin 1988 (Malts of Scotland)
  • Aberfeldy 12 Year Old
  • GlenDronach 1994 PX cask #3397
  • GlenDronach 1994 PX cask #326
  • GlenDronach 1993 Oloroso cask #494
  • Blair Athol 2002 (Hepburn's Choice)
  • Fettercairn Fior
  • Bowmore Laimrig 15yo
  • Ben Nevis 2002 (Port cask #334)

1601 notes by Ruben

WhiskyNotes - Ruben LuytenThis blog is my personal collection of impressions, written while searching for the ultimate single malt whisky.