Single malt whisky - tasting notes

Wemyss announced a new selection of single malts. There’s Bowmore 1995, Blair Athol 1991 and Glenrothes 1993 but we’ll try the Mortlach 1995, Aberfeldy 1999 and this Benriness 2001 ‘Rhubarb Royale’.



Benrinnes 2001 - Wemyss MaltsBenrinnes 2001 ‘Rhubarb Royale’ (46%, Wemyss Malts 2014, hogshead, 425 btl.)

Nose: a rather naked but fairly aromatic nose. Lots of juicy fruits, apple compote, pears, indeed some rhubarb jam as well. Yellow raisins and red berries. Hints of vanilla biscuits and honey. A few beer-like / malty notes as well. Mouth: bright and sweet again, with stewed fruits and wine gums. A bit youngish alright, but very pleasant. Rather floral at first, but it becomes more muscular over time, darker, with some toffee, hazelnuts and hints of mocha. Finish: medium long, with sweet spices and just a hint of savouriness.

This is just a really pleasant, bright and slightly understated Benrinnes. Very good middle-aged whisky.

Score: 86/100

This is the fourth bottling for the Limburg Dramclub. Buying this bottle makes you a member and gets you a ticket for the next Whisky Fair and a 5% online discount during a year. See

Although the label simply says Irish malt 2009, the spirit was supposedly produced at Cooley distillery (which makes it Tyrconnell).



Irish malt 2009 - Limburg DramclubIrish malt 6 yo 2009 (51,4%, Limburg Dramclub 2015, barrel, 141 btl.)

Nose: green Irish notes (pears, grapefruits, a little banana skin) but generally much grassier and grainier (sweet barley) than the ones produced at Bushmills. Subtle whiffs of nail polish remover as well. Muesli. Hints of vanilla. A bit of aniseed. Mouth: a slightly surprising mixture of juicy grapefruits, lemon zest, apple juice and a big mineral side. Some jelly beans. Huge ginger, with waxy notes, capsicum, green leafy notes… Herbs and bitter tonic. Finish: long, on ginger, liquorice and wax, with some candied touches.

An interesting dram, just don’t expect a fruit bomb. Kind of a Lowlands versions of Ireland. Around € 85, or € 65 if you only want the bottle without the other advantages. Also available outside of Limburg, or so it seems.

Score: 85/100

I’ve already tried the Glenfarclas 1971 cask #140 from the same series and Glenfarclas 1971 cask #148 for Silver Seal, all bottled in the same year.



glenfarclas-1971-family-cask-150Glenfarclas 40 yo 1971 (51%, OB Family Cask VII 2011, sherry butt #150, 468 btl.)

Nose: very vibrant – the sherry is big but not too loud. Plenty of plums, redcurrants and raspberry jam. Lovely polished oak. A little vanilla and treacle toffee. Rum & raisins. Very light hints of lemon candles. Very seductive. Mouth: fresh, again a really nice fruitiness of red berries, juicy plums and a little cranberry juice. Fruitcake. Honey. Liquorice. There’s a certain grassiness but no excessive wood. Finish: medium long, with the same grassiness but still fruity notes as well.

Always a pleasure, these old Glenfarclas Family Casks. This one is just as good as its siblings. Not sure what the original price was, now around € 500-650 now.

Score: 91/100

An undisclosed Islay Malt 2007 in the Liquid Treasures series. Other bottlers have released similar casks with a Kildalton reference (e.g. Kildalton 2007 Archives). So let’s keep it at Ardbeg again?



Islay Malt 2007 - Liquid TreasuresIslay Malt 7 yo 2007 (51,9%, Liquid Treasures 2014, bourbon barrel, 159 btl.)

Nose: lots of smoked fish, peated malt and clean lemony notes. A bit of tar and burnt heather. Roasted notes, like coffee and almonds. Clean and focused, but there’s a nice fat roundness to it (vanilla custard), as well as a mentholated edge. Mouth: quite sweet (vanilla syrup, pears and wine gums) before it gets peatier and more peppery. Smoked herbs. Fairly youngish in showing hints of fruit spirits. Liquorice sweets. Subtle earthy notes and gentian too. Finish: long, clean and ashy. Dark chocolate with a pinch of salt.

Bold whisky again, youngish but well made. Nowadays independent Islay whisky doesn’t come cheap though: around € 90.

Score: 87/100

Springbank 12 Years Cask Strength is matured in a combination of 70% sherry and 30% bourbon casks. The latest batch n°10 was bottled at 53,2%.

Its malt is first dried over a peat fire and then over hot air.



Springbank 12 Year Old - Cask StrengthSpringbank 12 yo ‘Cask Strength’ (53,2%, OB 2014, Batch 10, ref. 14/532)

Nose: typical Springbank notes like leather and wet chalk, with some zesty grapefruit and brine. Hints of grass. Sharp lemon. Some medicinal notes and smoke. There is however a rounder side to it, a bit of vanilla and dried coconut flakes. Mouth: surprisingly honeyed now. Sweet mint and pepper. Bags of lemon peel. After a while the grassy bitterness takes over and you get gingery notes and juniper. Liquorice and hints of pickle brine. The peat level seems a bit lower than in previous batches. Finish: long, bittersweet, with ashes and a lemon / salt combo.

Springbank really masters this profile. I seemed to like this one more than other batches, maybe because the peat is less prominent. Around € 65.

Score: 86/100

This Bunnahabhain 1988 from the latest batch of Wemyss releases was sold out in no-time. Just look at the colour and you know that you’re dealing with a heavy sherry influence.



Bunnahabhain 1988 Kirsch Gateau - WemyssBunnahabhain 26 yo 1988 ‘Kirsch Gateau’ (56%, Wemyss 2014, sherry butt, 442 btl.)

Nose: very rich and highly aromatic. A true sherry bomb. Lots of black cherries, ginjingha, rum & raisins, moeilleux with bits of raspberry, all the usual suspects really. Cinnamon and clove. Hints of walnuts. Very nice touches of polished oak as well. On par with the best GlenDronach releases. Mouth: similar chocolate cake associations, with red fruits, dates, cassis and cinnamon rolls. Molasses. Very thick, but also fairly dry after a while, with mint, cloves and the kind of dry oakiness of high-strength bourbons. Finish: not as long as expected, but a tad rounder again. Figs and spices.

Pretty great Bunnahabhain if you’re into sherry bombs. You’ll also have to stand some oak, mid-palate. Bloody intense and definitely up there with GlenDronach. Around € 160. Thanks Wim.

Score: 89/100

Earlier this month, The BenRiach launched two new cask finishes: the BenRiach 15 years old Sauternes finish and this BenRiach 18 years old Albariza, which is a peated whisky finished in Pedro Ximénez sherry casks.

Albariza is a white chalky soil, typical for Andalucia but similar to the soils of Champagne or Chablis. Nowadays around 90% of the vineyards in the sherry region are planted on Albariza (although mainly with Palomino grapes, not Pedro Ximénez).

The BenRiach Albariza is distilled from peated malt. It was first matured in American oak casks and then finished in PX casks.



BenRiach Albariza - 18 yearsBenRiach 18 yo Albariza (46%, OB 2015, peated – PX finish, 3886 btl.)

Nose: I picked up the sharpness of the peat first, but it mellows as the glass warms up. A very nice, jammy fruitiness as well. Vanilla ice cream with raspberry topping. Dried apricots. Fig syrup and Turkish delights. Big notes of honey. The peatiness is still there but the aromatic sweetness wins. Mouth: slightly thinner than expected maybe, and more focused on the peaty side now. Yellow raisins and subtle vanilla. Quite some peppery and gingery notes. Leafy notes and peat. Finish: medium long, drier and spicier, with hints of dark chocolate.

The luscious nose was very good, but the BenRiach Albariza looses a few points on the palate, where it becomes thinner and the oak is bigger than the PX. Around € 95.

Score: 87/100

Oddbins selected a whole series of Glen Garioch casks in the second half of the 1990’s. There was a 1966, 1967, 1971 and this 1972 vintage. All of them say ‘bottled from a single cask’ but no further information is given. No age, not even a bottling year…

There is very little Glen Garioch 1972 to be found. Remember the distillery was mothballed in 1968 due to chronic water shortages and sold to Stanley P. Morrison in 1970. In 1972, Joe Hughes was appointed as manager, and he found another water source that was more reliable. In that same year, a distillery expansion was started, with an increase from two to three (and then to four) stills.

It’s interesting how years of change and expansion often lead to excellent results, because they disrupt the normal processes. The whisky is produced in ways that were not considered to be most favourable (or most economic), but sometimes it takes a turn for the better. Bowmore 1993 is another great example of this.



Glen Garioch 1972 - OddbinsGlen Garioch 1972 (43%, OB for Oddbins, single cask, 1990’s)

Nose: complex stuff. It starts on silver polish and mineral peat, with a delicate sootiness. Mint and eucalyptus. The sherry notes are old-style, think tobacco leaves, leather boots and blackberry jam. Chalky notes and hints of old books. There are whiffs of tropical fruits as well (grapefruits, dried mango) which grow stronger over time, but overall they are a little softer than in some other old Glen Garioch examples. Nonetheless pretty wonderful. Mouth: much more peaty now, and more wonderfully tropical as well. What a dram. Seville oranges, Earl Grey tea, deep soot and plenty of spices like cloves and cardamom. Minty notes and resinous wood. Delicate herbs. Something of mustard seed. Less sherried than I expected – this is a slightly thin style but a very complex one. Finish: long, with spicy fruit cake, a gentle bitterness, coastal notes and lingering smoke. Leaves your mouth full of tobacco.

Glen Garioch made some pretty exceptional whisky these days, close to Brora’s profile sometimes. Just wonderful. Heartfelt thanks, Carsten (who else?).

Score: 94/100



November 2015
« Oct    

Coming up

  • Lindores 2015 festival bottling
  • Amrut 2009 (cask #2701)
  • Glenlivet 1981 (#9468 for TWE)
  • Lagavulin Distillers Edition (2015)
  • Talisker Distillers Edition (2015)
  • Laphroaig 32 Year Old
  • Glen Grant 65yo 1950 cask #2747 for Wealth Solutions
  • Mortlach 1959/1960 (G&M Royal Wedding)

1931 notes by Ruben

WhiskyNotes - Ruben LuytenThis blog is my personal collection of impressions, written while searching for the ultimate single malt whisky.